2020年5月1日到15日，FX168点评旗舰店收到以及舆情监控用户点评共计57条，其中，好评为23条，差评为29条。以下为本期半月报的用户点评信息整理。
一、差评情况
在此期间收到的29条差评中，对客服支持不到位的投诉最多，有9条；跟出金有关的差评共计6条；平台恶意操纵账户导致客户订单获利损失的6条；点差相关的投诉2条；滑点1条；其它类型的投诉为5条。以下是被投诉经纪商的差评数量展示：
此期间收到差评的经纪商包括：
嘉盛，Admiral Markets Pty艾迪麦，avatrade，FBS，IG（停止服务大陆客户），RoboForex，Tickmill，alpari艾福瑞，EXNESS，IC Markets，IFC Markets，Swissquote瑞讯银行，TeleTrade特理汇，VANTAGE FX，杜高斯贝银行，共计15家经纪商。（按差评数量从多到少排序）
图片来源：FX168点评旗舰店用户点评红黑榜（2020.05.16）
5月1日至15日，嘉盛集团的客诉较为集中，共计收到7条客诉，且覆盖了出入金、客服、账户操纵及其他等多方面的问题，反馈问题的用户基本全部来自北美地区。 例如有加拿大地区的客户在5月2日投诉：我在嘉盛经历了一次很糟糕的事情。事情是这样的，我本来有个原油空单，开市后，原油价格突然大幅下跌，然后我的单子就被关闭了。几个小时内，我在我的持仓单中都找不到这笔单子。几个小时后，当订单再次出现时，这笔单子已经亏损了。我和在线客服沟通，在线客服表示是因为有一个错误的价格导致了价格下跌，进而导致了我近3个小时都没办法操作我的订单。客服说它将被"修复"，我将收到一封电子邮件。我告诉我需要的只是取消我的订单，电话等待了一个多小时，没有答案。已经很晚了。第二天还是没有结果。这笔订单由于嘉盛的技术故障而消失了几个小时，到我可以关闭交易的时候，已经有很大的亏损了，这难道不应该由嘉盛来承担吗？
其余部分差评内容：
RoboForex：请避免与RoboForex交易，我开设了这个帐户21003360，并在3天后无故关闭。 我尝试联系他们的团队是因为我认为这是错误的，因为我从未使用该帐户进行交易，但没有得到任何回复。
IC Markets：在IC Markets已经交易很多年了，从未对客户服务如此失望。之前他们说石油差价合约的保证金要求已更改，并被告知有一封电子邮件发送给客户，但我从未收到（是的，已检查垃圾邮件文件夹，它不存在。所有其他电子邮件，如对帐单和支持电子邮件都没有问题）。向他们询问是否将我包括在邮件列表中；如果没有，请添加我，但他们除了重复发送给客户的电子邮件外没有做任何其他事情。问他们为什么多次禁用WTI_M0进行交易，他们只是忽略了该问题并在上面重复。
Admiral Markets：我在Admiral Markets的经历太荒唐了，我仍然不敢相信，我在不同的经纪人中开了4个帐户：Admiral Markets和其他3个经纪商，我用信用卡分别建立了每个1500美元的帐户，其他3个帐户都很好，但是当我为Admiral Markets入金时，这笔钱从我的信用卡余额中扣除了， 但是却没有在账户上显示出来，后来，我收到Admiral Markets的一封电子邮件，说他们的财务部门暂时暂停了我的入金并保留了这笔钱。 因为："发送的详细信息包含无效的数据或不匹配的信息"，信用卡都是同一个，为什么其他3家就没事呢？我不知道该怎么办...
万致：已有3周了，我仍然没有收到万致vantage fx的出金的通知。 他们已经清空了我的帐户，而且出金也不知所踪。 我花了1个小时才能接通万致vantage fx的电话，接听电话时，他们说他们已经付款了。 我去了银行，参考号什么也没。 他们现在说他们已经付款了，无法执行任何操作。 他们无法撤回或追踪，我的银行应使用收据给我钱。 银行却告诉我并没有，他们在撒谎。
其余更多用户投诉内容，用户可到各经纪商旗舰店内页查看。
二、好评情况
5月1日至15日，收到好评的经纪商有：GKFX Prime，GKFX捷凯金融，TeleTrade特理汇，FXTM富拓，IC Markets，OctaFX，兴业投资，AxiTrader，FP Markets，FXCM福汇，OANDA安达，Pepperstone激石（取消中国办事处），亨达集团（按好评数量从多到少排序），用户予以好评的理由也集中在出入金的顺畅上，可见近来客户对于此方面的重视。
IC Markets近一个月的好评垄断被打破，TeleTrade特理汇，GKFX捷凯金融，GKFX Prime都以3条好评的成绩共同冲到了本周期内好评数量排行榜的榜首。
有用户评论称：对我来说，作为金融市场的新手，Teletrade原来是一个非常不错的选择。首先，之所以选择Teletrade，是因为其获得了积极的评价和可承受的成本。我刚开始只投资了100美元，只想检查一下其他交易者的结果（如果他们愿意的话），这让我非常有动力学习专业交易。我看了大师班，读了关于交易和心理学的书。在开始的时候，我低估了思维方式的重要性，这导致了帐户余额的负面结果。我仅两周就损失了$50，我不明白为什么。我不能说我在猜测方向，根据技术分析，一切似乎都已完成。我对该计划所做的微小更改似乎并不重要，但实际上确实如此！我又存了200美元，把钱分成了一半。我把50%的操作留给了自己，另一半则通过复制交易平台来遵循另一位交易者的系统。即使我自己不再损失那么多钱，但现在我可以清楚地看到-很难争论的数字-交易需要更多的经验。如果我增加投资，我将朝着使复制交易组合多样化的方向发展。很高兴Teletrade提供这个机会！。
用户评价GKFX捷凯金融称：老平台，放心，并且现在能对公账户的已经不多了，希望捷凯能一直这么稳定的做下去，那样我也不用为选择平台而担忧。
也有用户评价HYCM：必须承认，在这动荡的时期内，兴业投资HYCM依然表现的不错，虽然市场波动率极大，但是兴业的订单执行力仍然很好。
其余更多用户点评内容，用户可到各经纪商旗舰店内页查看。
From May 1st to 15th, 2020, FX168 Broker Review received and monitored a total of 57 reviews from users, of which 23 were positive and 29 were negative. The following is a summary of the user review information for this half-monthly report.
1. Negative Reviews
Among the 29 negative reviews received during this period, there were the most complaints about the poor customer service support, which had 9; a total of 6 negative reviews related to the withdrawal of funds; 6 complaints about the platform's malicious manipulation of accounts that led to the loss of profit from customer orders; 2 negative reviews about spreads and 1 related to slip points; 5 other types of complaints. The following is the display of the number of negative reviews of the complained broker:
Brokers received negative reviews during this period include：
Forex.com，Admiral Markets Pty，avatrade，FBS，IG（Stop serving mainland customers），RoboForex，Tickmill，alpari，EXNESS，IC Markets，IFC Markets，Swissquote，TeleTrade，VANTAGE FX，Dukascopy Bank，totally 15 brokers.( Sorted by number of negative reviews, from less to more ).
Image source: FX168 Brokers reviews -user reviews Red Black List（16.05.2020）
From May 1st to 15th, Forex.com's customer complaints were relatively concentrated, and there are 5 in total. It covered many issues such as deposits and withdrawals, customer service, account manipulation and etc. The users who feedback the problems are basically from North America. For example, a customer from Canada complained on May 2:
This is the worst experience I ever had. I had a Crude oil sell order at 1398. After the trade is opened for some time, the price suddenly spiked down all the way to 888, and my order was closed. It was not on my open order screen for few hours. The order then reappeared few hours later, but it was a loosing trade when it came back. The issue is I have no idea and no control on my trade for about 3 hours. I would have been able to close it sooner if I have control of it. I chat with Vincent, he told me that they have a wrong price printed and causing the price to spike down. He said it will be "fixed" and I will get an email. I told him to just cancel my order and pretend it never happened. He asked me to call customer service. I was put on hold for over one hour and no answer. It was late in the evening. I chat with Ryan the next morning. The trade is loosing even more now. I asked Ryan to just cancel the trade but he refused. I got transferred to his supervisor. He said it is my responsibility to manage my trade, which is a big BS because the order disappeared for few hours because it was their technical glitch. He said I can close the trade now if I want to, but it's a big loosing trade already. All this started from their technical glitch and I was not informed at all. The trade was out of my screen for few hours, when every second matters when trading. I have to take a big lost because I did not anything wrong. What a freaking bad business ethic. I am just a small trader, maybe they don't care. Simply disgusted. Never ever come back. Stay to hell away from them.
Some negative reviews:
RoboForex: Please please traders avoid roboforex like a plague. This broker Roboforex is full of itself, i opened this account 21003360 and after 3 days it was closed with no reason. I tried reaching their team because I thought it was a error as I never traded with the account but I got no reply.
IC Markets:
I have been with ICM for years, such a big disappointment with the customer service.
Notice the margin requirement changed for Oil CFDs, and and was told there was an email sent to clients, which I never receive (yes, checked spam folder, it is not there. All other emails like account statements and support emails no issue).
Requested them if I was included in the mailing list, and if not, please add me in, but they did not do anything than just repeating email sent to clients.
Asked them why WTI_M0 is disabled for trading for many times, and they just ignore that question and repeat above.
Contact my IB, which directed me back to ICM. It's a dead loop.
To ICM, if you are reading this, please look into the quality of customer service.
Admiral Markets：
This is incredible guys, I still can't believe it,I opened 4 accounts in different brokers: Admiral Markets and 3 others, I founded everything with $ 1500 each, from my credit card, all good with the other 3, but when I financed Admiral Markets, the money disappeared from my credit card balance and was not funded My admiral account, later, i received an email from them saying that their financing department temporarily suspended my deposit and kept the money. Because: "the details sent have invalid data or information that does not match", they said that from the same credit card that I used to fund the other brokers !, I am in shock, they only keep the money and I did not receive any other mail from them, I don't know what to do...
VANTAGE FX:
It's been 3 weeks and I still haven't recieved my withdrawal. They've emptied my account and have made the payment go missing. They take 1 hour to get through to over the phone, when they pick up they say they've send the payment. I went to my bank and the reference number doesn't return anything. They are now saying they've send the payment and can't do anything. They can't retract or trace and that my bank should give me the money using the receipt. Bank have advised me that they are lying and can retract payment and that their receipt is invalid. Avoid this broker if you want to be able to get your money back! Worst customer service and makes your money go missing
The rest of the user complaints can be viewed on the other pages of the FX168 Broker reviews.
2.Positive Reviews
From May 1st to 15th, 2020，brokers received positive reviews during this period include:：GKFX Prime，GKFX，TeleTrade，FXTM，IC Markets，OctaFX，HYCM，AxiTrader，FP Markets，FXCM，OANDA，Pepperstone（China office has been cancelled），Hantec Group(Sorted by number of bad reviews, from less to more).The reason why users praise it is also focused on the smoothness of deposits and withdrawals, which shows that customers have recently paid attention to this aspect.
In the past month, IC Markets' number of positive reviews is no longer at the top of the list. TeleTrade, GKFX, and GKFX Prime all rushed to the top of the list in the current cycle with 3 positive reviews.
A users commented:
For me, as a newcomer to financial markets, Teletrade turned out to be a very nice option.
First I planned to trade myself solely. The broker was chosen because of positive reviews and affordable starting point. I invested only $100 in the beginning and just wanted to check how everything will go.
The fact that other traders results (if they wanted) were shown in rankings, kept me highly motivated to learn to trade professionally. I watched endless masterclasses, read books on trading and psychology. In the beginning I underestimated the importance of the mindset and this lead to a negative result on the account balance. I've lost $50 in only 2 weeks and I couldn't understand why. I can't say I was guessing the direction, everything seemed to be done according to the tech analysis. The minor changes I was making to the plan didn't seem important, but they were in fact!
I deposited another $200 and split the money in half. 50% I left for myself, and the other half was used to follow the other trader's system through a copy-trading platform. Even though I stopped losing that much myself, I can clearly see now - the numbers are difficult to argue with - that trading requires more experience. If I invest more, I'll be looking more in a direction of diversifying the copy trading portfolio. Glad that the broker offers this opportunity!
A user evaluated GKFX: GKFX is an old platform, so I am very relieved. And now there are not many public accounts, I hope GKFX can continue to run so stably, so I don't have to worry about choosing a reliable platform
A user evaluated HYCM：It must be admitted that during this turbulent period, HYCM still performed well. Although market volatility is extremely high, HYCM's order execution is still very good.
The rest of the user complaints can be viewed on the other pages of the FX168 Broker reviews.
